1981 St. John’s Basketball: A Promising Season Unravels
Lou Carnesecca had the St. John’s basketball program in a good place. The Redmen had reached five straight NCAA Tournaments, and in an era where the size of the field ranged from 32 to 40 teams. They were a contender in the newly formed Big East Conference. The 1981 St. John’s basketball season marked a step back thanks to a late fade, before the success picked up a year later.
FORWARDS THAT NEEDED HELP
The ’81 Redmen were built around their forwards, David Russell and Wayne McKoy. Russell averaged 15 points/8 rebounds per game, and McKoy was right behind him at 14/7.
Where the problem came in was height—the 6’8” Russell and the 6’7” McKoy were the tallest players in the regular rotation, and at a time when taller, more traditional post players were used by most teams.
The other problem was punch—no one else scored in double figures. Carnesecca pieced together a combination of Billy Goodwin, Fran Gilroy, Kevin Williams, and Curtis Redding that was respectable, but ultimately not enough to get St. John’s over the hump.
LITTLE WARNING SIGNS
Ranked #17 in the preseason polls, the Redmen won their first three games. That included a 67-58 win over James Madison, who ultimately made the Round of 32 in the NCAA Tournament. It also included a 68-62 win over Penn, the eventual runner-up in the Ivy League.
But St. John’s dropped a tight 47-46 decision to Princeton, who won the Ivy. On the Friday and Saturday after Christmas, they played consecutive games at Madison Square Garden. A second win over Penn was heartening. A nine-point loss to mediocre N.C. State was disturbing. The Redmen went into the new calendar year with a record of 7-2, but had fallen from the rankings.
A FAST START IN THE BIG EAST
1981 was the first season the now eight-team Big East was freed up to play a complete double round-robin conference schedule. St. John’s traveled to play a good Villanova team. The Redmen played well and won 90-78, then came home and knocked off NCAA Tournament-bound Georgetown 68-60.
A blowout win over lowly Providence followed, and St. John’s got another win over Villanova, this one a 56-54 nailbiter. The Redmen were 4-0 in league play and riding high.
THE THICK OF THE RACE
Momentum slowed with a one-point loss at UConn and a 79-71 defeat at Syracuse, the first time St. John’s visited the new Carrier Dome facility. Those losses were sandwiched around a 73-62 win over so-so Seton Hall. They briefly stepped outside the league to close January, beating Niagara and a competitive Fordham team.
Boston College was one of several contenders in what was shaping up as a packed Big East race. The Redmen welcomed the Eagles into Madison Square Garden in early February and beat them 76-71. St. John’s lost their rematch with Georgetown but took a measure of revenge on UConn.
A high-profile non-conference game went down on Valentine’s Day, a Saturday afternoon. Oregon State, ranked #2 in the nation came east and the game was played in Nassau Coliseum, normally the home of the Stanley Cup champion New York Islanders. St. John’s lost 57-45.
But losing to a nationally elite team was no shame and the low score, in an era of no shot clock and no three-point line was hardly unusual. What mattered is that St. John’s was 7-3 in the Big East, tied for first with Boston College. Georgetown and UConn were a game back, Villanova was two off the pace and Syracuse was still angling for an NCAA Tournament invite.
Everything was on the table in the Big East as the latter part of February arrived.
TEN DAYS THAT CHANGED EVERYTHING
A Monday night visit to Providence was a colossal disaster—losing to the league’s worst team was problem enough, but at 73-57 it wasn’t particularly competitive. The Redmen had a chance to revive themselves up in Boston but dropped a 59-58 heartbreaker at BC. They went to Seton Hall and lost 70-63.
In the span of just ten days, they had fallen to 7-6 in the Big East and were effectively out of the league race. At the very least, they were still 16-9, the NCAA field had been expanded to 48 teams for 1981, and there was hope of getting a bid.
An 82-73 win over Syracuse at MSG kept St. John’s alive going into the Big East Tournament. The tradition of the tournament being played in New York City hadn’t started yet, and the Carrier Dome was hosting. The Redmen had to play the Orange again in the quarterfinals, and this time they lost, 71-66.
St. John’s fell short of the NCAAs. They settled for an NIT bid. But the late season fade continued. They hosted a middle-of-the-pack Alabama team and immediately lost again, a 73-69 overtime decision. A once-promising 1981 campaign ended with an empty thud.
A BRIEF DETOUR
The string of NCAA Tournament appearances was over, but Carnesecca had help on the way. A pair of recruits by the names of Chris Mullin and Bill Wennington arrived in 1982 and a fresh streak of NCAA invites began. This one included a trip to the Final Four in 1985. The 1981 finish proved to be nothing more than a bump in the road.
